Q.

A cylindrical tank has a hole of diameter 2r in its bottom. The hole is covered by a wooden cylindrical block of diameter 4r, height h and density ρ/3.

Situation I: Initially, the tank is filled with water of density ρ to a height such that the height of water above the top of the block is h1 (measured from the top of the block).

Situation II: The water is removed from the tank to a height h2 (measured from the bottom of the block), as shown in the figure. The height h2 is smaller than h (height of the block) and thus the block is exposed to the atmosphere.

Q.     In situation 2, if h2 is further decreased, then                       [2006]

1 cylinder will not move up and remains at its original position  
2 for h2=h3, cylinder again starts moving up  
3 for h2=h4, cylinder again starts moving up  
4 for h2=h5, cylinder again starts moving up  

Ans.

(1)

In situation - 2 when the height h2 of water level is further decreased, then the upward force acting on the wooden block decreases. The total force downward remains the same. This difference will be compensated by the normal reaction by the tank wall on the wooden block. Hence the block does not moves up and remains at its original position.